Skip to main content.

Monday, April 14, 2008

By Emily Low, Courier Opinion Writer

Do not do your homework while listening to music.

The above statement is one the student has heard time and time again, from parents, teachers, and, heavens forbid, even his or her own nerdy friends. Of course, the reprimand does not just apply to music, but any other distraction as well, such as television or the telephone or even a friend nearby.

I must admit, I am most certainly guilty of violating the order myself. As I sit at this laptop clicking away on the keyboard, Brahms’ clarinet trio is floating out of the speakers. It can’t hurt, anyway, I reason; this is creative stuff, not…studying and memorization. And it has no lyrics, right? No distraction there.


Is that really a legitimate excuse? I’m sure we all have one in one form or the other. But let’s put them to the test. Does it really hurt?

Try picking up a novel and reading it for five minutes with a distraction squealing about in the background. Then, put down the book and lean back. Think a bit. What did you just read?

For me, the answer will almost always be the same: Something along the lines of this or that…I think. I dunno.

Like most people, while I claim to be able to multitask, the fact is that I’m not all too efficient about it. Can I scribble down a poem for English while my friends talk beside me? Well, yes. But does the poem sound good? No. And what were my friends just talking about? I really don’t have much of a clue.

For me, distractions are just that: distractions. I am horrible at continuing my train of thought, my flow of mood, my ribbon of relevant information. It’s not necessarily that I forget what I’m writing so much as it is that I cannot get past the barrier provided by that distraction. Like for most others, concentrating on an assignment of any sort is difficult when there’s so much noise about. I work fifty times as slow, and am .01% as productive.

This observation has become especially rooted since homework has piled up on me this year. I need to find time to do it all, but there are only so many free hours in a day! I attempt to do my homework during another class, during lunch, in periods where I’m not assigned much for the day…but I get absolutely nothing done. It’s frustrating; I need to cram, but I’m not able to. Am I the only one who suffers from this ailment? I think not. For my own selfish sake, I hope not. I don’t want to be alone in my boat.

Thus, attempts to rectify the situation have sprouted. Uh…I’ll do all my studying at home when it’s quieter, I suppose. And hey! It worked! I got my homework done in three hours instead of five! I really do work better without noise.

And you can’t deny the fact that most people believe that, really. Think about it. We take tests in quiet rooms (for the most part). We rehearse performances with chitchat kept to a minimum. We take notes in hushed lecture halls. Perhaps we do perform better in the silence.

With that said, I kindly command you to do your next homework assignment without music. I’ve turned mine off.

Too bad my sister has begun to practice her clarinet.

If you spot any mistakes, accept my sincere apologies. I blame it on the lack of silence.

Comments

It's great to see this from a student's point of view. Adults can talk and talk but until a teen figures it out for themselves it's just noise. Thanks for giving it a try and realizing that what parents and teachers say may be for your own good.

Posted by silverstudent at Monday, April 14, 2008 16:20:35

NEVER! If you are basing all your information on anecdotes and permissive presumptions, then how do you explain my A+ in my freshman year algebra 2? I listened to music during all lectures, tests, quizzes, classwork and homework. It wasn't until the last day of class Mr. Prucha noticed an ear-bud lodged in my left ear and demanded I take it out.

Posted by Sav at Tuesday, April 15, 2008 12:05:36

I've found that listening to music helps me concentrate while doing certain subjects, like math and science, but listening to it while trying to read for english or answer word problems I have some major issues. My dad and I both actually work better when it comes to math and science when there is a lot of noise going on around us. And I know I write better when I'm listening to music. I think it all just depends on the person.

Posted by Stewart at Tuesday, April 15, 2008 17:40:44

I agree with Stewart, it really depends on the person and the subject.

When I do my homework at home, I just about always have the radio on, and it does actually halp me concentrate I think.

When I decide not to do my homework at home, I end up doing it at lunch, and a majority of the time there are many conversations going on around me. Although I know it takes a bit longer to do homework while talking, I can still get it done and most of the time it really isn't so bad. :)

Posted by pippy at Tuesday, April 15, 2008 18:54:46

I agree with Stewart, it really depends on the person and the subject.

When I do my homework at home, I just about always have the radio on, and it does actually halp me concentrate I think.

When I decide not to do my homework at home, I end up doing it at lunch, and a majority of the time there are many conversations going on around me. Although I know it takes a bit longer to do homework while talking, I can still get it done and most of the time it really isn't so bad. :)

Posted by pippy at Tuesday, April 15, 2008 18:56:03

Add Comment