Skip to main content.

Saturday, March 03, 2007

By Roberta Maas, Courier Staff Writer

James Logan's production of The Music Man Friday night was neither a disappointment nor satisfying.

The musical was not consistent. On occasion the performances were quite believable. During other scenes, however, the singing was extremely off key and lines were entirely forgotten. The male portion of the cast suffered from this memory loss most frequently.


Joseph Canuto who played Harold Hill stumbled incessantly over his lines. I was surprised that the main character was so unprepared.

The costuming was impressive for a high school production. The sets could have used some help; you could even tell that the paint on the backdrop was still wet.

The musical boasted an orchestra that unfortunately overpowered the actors. A majority of the time, while the orchestra was playing, I could not even hear the lines that the actors were saying. They did have mikes for a few of the main characters but they cut in and out.

Some fine talent could be seen at the musical. Aarti Bhatnagar who played Marian Paroo was truly wonderful in her part. Her acting, singing and dancing were without fault.

[Courier staffer] Victoria McDonald, who played Mrs. Paroo, Marian's mother, even adopted an Irish accent for her role and demonstrated her crocheting skills onstage. Who knew that she could crochet?

I would recommend seeing the musical purely for the effort that the students put into the production.
You can tell that the students have a passion for what they do and it shines through to produce a musical that is truly heartfelt.

Comments

I know we could have been better, and there is no excuse, but I think that Sunday will end up being our best because it will be the last day and we will most likely be more comfortable with what we are doing. I know the whole cast had a lot of fun putting on this show for you guys, and I hope that tonight and Sunday will be better for those of you watching. Thank you for being honest, and now that we know what we need to work on I think we can fix it. Thank you for watching our show and everyone else comes out to watch it too =)

Posted by pippy at Saturday, March 03, 2007 14:24:42

[Don't be mean]

Posted by hater at Sunday, March 04, 2007 17:28:26

You are crazy! That play was absolutly stunning! Alot of hard work and effort went into that play and your just jealous because you tried out for the play and didnt make it! Stop being all [edited] hurt and get over it! You just werent good enough, move on with your life and stop taking your anger out on the talented people! Everybody knew their lines and provided them with flair. Joseph did an amazing job portraying his character Harold Hill and say with excellence! None of the sets were wet as they had been painted 2 days prior to the opening of the play. Also if you couldnt hear the actors and actresses lines it would be because of your own personal hearing problems and not of the cast! Another thing would have to be that a proffesional actor that toured with The Music Man for 9 months and played a major role in it thought that it was great and loved every second of it so you obviously dont know talent when you see it! Get a life!

Posted by TomsGirl at Sunday, March 04, 2007 19:37:44

The Music Man!

Posted by Jolly at Sunday, March 04, 2007 20:09:47

Aarti Bhatnagar was by far the star of the show! W/o her, the musical wouldn't have been nearly as good as it was.

Posted by sobe at Sunday, March 04, 2007 21:36:38

How can you say the singing was off key? do you know what off key sounds like? and I'd like to see YOU try memorizing lines. Word for word. We all did our best.

Posted by kase. at Monday, March 05, 2007 00:00:54

yo. It was alright. I dont completely agree with what was said, although some of it was true. It wasn't horrible, matter of fact, i enjoyed it to a degree. The singing was done well and it was executed powerfully thanks to the hard owrk that everyone put into it. Unfortunately, the orcestra was louder than individual members, but it's because of the was the stage is built. You recieve the reverbriated sound of them easier than the ensemble. I believe that we all put our hardest into what we did there, and I hope that everyone enjoyed it as much as we did. Jeely Kly, give us a break!

Posted by DAVID COLLINS at Monday, March 05, 2007 08:43:28

Get a life it's a high school production...what did you expect..its not broadway!!!! it wasnt ment to be perfect.... as long as you could go and see fellow class mates working hard you should be proud and not mean... SHOW SOME SCHOOL SPIRIT!!!!! i agree with the other fans of the show...you should open your eys and be a kid...you are too young to be this critical!!! the show was just fine!!!

Posted by quiet please! at Monday, March 05, 2007 10:25:00

THE PAINT WAS NOT WET!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by THE PAINTER HERSELF!!! at Monday, March 05, 2007 10:28:28

You MUST be blind to have wrote that review are you sure you even went to go watch the musical?! The Musical was GREAT! Singing was hella good! Off key? gotta be def to say that.

Posted by Rizza at Monday, March 05, 2007 11:22:59

Obviously the writer doesn't have any idea what the hell she is talking about. I'm sorry, but when a professional (A PROFESSIONAL) actor who toured with the musical for 9 months thought it was wonderful, then she has ruined her credibility in writing this review. It must have taken some major guts for Ms. Maas to come up to me after the show on Friday and lie to my face to tell me that "I loved the show, it was great" and then go home and write about how we were unprepared and that we sang off-key and it was a "heartfelt attempt" at a show. Sorry, you lost this reader's (and writer's) respect and, quite possibly, her trust.

Posted by Pick-A-Little at Monday, March 05, 2007 12:14:57

Honestly. Before you critique a high school musical or any type of musical you should know something about singing, acting, and dancing. Your stupidity angers me. And for your information people spend months working on this production and to hear a bad review from and unimformed ignorant writer, does not help convince people to join your program. And also a writer who makes reviews should make constructive criticism rather that destructive criticism. thank you.

Posted by anonymous at Monday, March 05, 2007 14:10:06

I believe you have no idea about music to be able to critique. This shows that you have no knowledge of singing, acting, and dancing. How you be a writing when you know nothing about how to critique such production. It an insult to those who worked hard for the production. I surely know they articulated and were on the correct key. You should learn more about music before critiquing a musical. You give a bad representation of the courier.

Posted by anonymous at Monday, March 05, 2007 14:19:13

I was not in the musical nor I know anyone who participated in the musical, but I attended the musical. Everything that you wrote was false about the musical. You show that you are an uneducated person toward muscial productions. It shows that you have no interest in these activities that you write your own opinion toward the muscial because you were assigned to go to the production to critique it. Whoever approved of this article to be published should consider a new job. Do not do anymore critique on musicals until you have knowledge about musicals. If you have any knowledge, it just shows that you don't .

Posted by your best friend at Monday, March 05, 2007 14:28:21

You obviously have NO idea what you are talking about.The musical was great sure it wasnt perfect but come on this is HIGH SCHOOL!!! It isnt suppose to be perfect. The cast,crew,and directors put so much into the musical to make it happen. You have NO right to call people out on their mistakes! You try going up in front of a large audience and sing,and dance,and act ALL at the same time. Guess what hunny....It isnt easy!!! Its not our fault that you didn't make the show. But at least be respectful of the people who did! We did our best to make this show happen!!! ALL of the directors were so happy with what we did. So you need to really reconsider this whole writing thing because if you are going to write about things that are false then you shouldn't write at all!!!

Posted by Fellow Pick A Little Lady at Monday, March 05, 2007 15:44:50

And you call yourelf a writer??

Posted by Jason Hernandez at Monday, March 05, 2007 16:56:54

I believe, like many people, that you have no idea what you were saying, we were not "extremely off key". Joseph did exceptionally well especially considering how many lines he had and how he had a tempo for a lot of it. The paint was NOT wet, a lot of us worked hard on finishing it in time. If you think that it is so easy, you should try putting yourself in Joseph, or any of our, shoes. We had to perform for 3 days straight, some people, such as Joseph, were on stage almost the entire show. It's really stressful and it's a pain, those clothes are heavy and the shoes are a pain. Most of us were stressing out in the back and outside after the show, but we never showed it on stage. And the directors were very happy with it, and it's really hard to make them like their own production, especially with Mr. Vega pretty much hating the musical since he's in it and he's seen it millions of times.

Posted by Man#2 at Monday, March 05, 2007 17:02:18

dude seriously this review blows. Joseph Canuto was wonderful and you are extremely out of line by saying that he was "so unprepared." I'll have you know that Joseph and everyone else in the cast worked so hard to pull this musical through. And considering where we started, I think we did an awesome job. So until you can show everyone that you can do everything that our cast, crew and directors had to do, don't try and tell us that our show wasn't good enough.

Posted by someone who was in the musical at Monday, March 05, 2007 17:47:32

Are u sure u are a writer cause I totally disagree with u. This was the best musical Logan have done. Everything was so cool from the costumes, setting, and the vocals especially Joseph and Aarti they were the best!!!!Also, the whole cast was really amazing. I guess u don't know anything about musicals!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by anonymous at Monday, March 05, 2007 17:49:33

U are a ^$%^% #@@%@ #$#$!$#$!!!!! I have seen that those people work really hard, in this show. How dare u said that Joseph was "unprepared" he did a magnificient job. This was one of the most hard musicals we have done and I think we did a really good job. anyways no one cares what u said because people that went to the show came out with a happy face and telling us that was the best show we have done. I want u to see in fron of the entire theater trying to do half of what we did the three nights. I can said that u weren't be able to entertain the people like we did....

Posted by someone who worked in the show!!!!!!!!!! at Monday, March 05, 2007 17:55:29

You poor little actors.

Did someone not like your little production?

Perhaps you thought this was like kindergarten, when the parents would applaud you for anything.

Grow up! If you're going to put yourself on stage and be an actor, learn to take the good comments with the bad, and try to do better.

What should the writer have done? Lie if she thought you stank on toast? Is that what we want from our journalists?

It's probably what you want, in fact, but the audience would like to see honest opinions expressed, not fake praise.

How could you learn to be better if you don't hear criticism?

Plus, you're horrible hypocrites. You think your performances can't be viewed negatively, but you're quick to heap scorn on another student who's just doing her job! Hypocrites! Cry-Baby Hypocrites.

Get off the stage and leave it to someone who can take it.

Posted by Drammies Suck at Monday, March 05, 2007 18:18:19

I must have seen the same production that the writer did, except what I saw was way worse.

The geese on the big green are more tuneful than some of the singers on stage that night.

Some key players seemed unable to remember which parts they were acting.

No doubt, some of the cast did a fine job. Praiseworthy, in fact.

But, on the whole, boooooooooooo!

Posted by Honestly, It Was Bad at Monday, March 05, 2007 18:33:31

i am not a mbeerm of the cast, but i wnt to the show with afreind of somone who is and I DoN't thing i likd it.

Posted by Wetn an saw at Monday, March 05, 2007 18:36:02

I'm obviously a little biased when it comes to the subject of this review and its subsequent comments. After all, I work for the Courier. The newspaper is something very near and dear to my heart. That being said, however, I think I can take myself outside of my own subjectivity to defend what I think is a legitimate review.

1) It says a lot about the maturity of those who comment on an article like this when personal attacks are brought in. She said something unfavorable about the production, sure, but it is the absolutely height of bad taste to insult the poor girl because of their idea differs from your own. "You're just jealous because you tried out and didn't make it". I suppose you're mad at Roberta for stealing your binky and eating the last cookie before naptime, too.

2) While highly doubtful (a review, after all, is subjective material), perhaps Roberta may have erred when she wrote the unfavorable review about the musical. Maybe it really was just that "stunning" and she actually has no right to critique it. However, using the logic utilized by those who left comments, the James Logan Courier is indeed a high school publication. If the musical is not to be held up to the same standards that Broadway productions are beholden to, then it logically follows that this review shouldn't be held up to the standards the Wall Street Journal has to abide by.

3) Teacher At Logan: There's a difference between trying to help a student realize the error of her ways and mercilessly flinging insults her way under the shield of anonymity. Not only is it unacceptable to call Roberta a "bad writer" when you can't even distinguish between "your" and "you're" (example: you're wrong, your opinion is invalid), but to do so without giving up your identity so that she can adequately defend herself is cowardly. And as long as we're making unfounded claims, I contend that you're a horrible educator because you can't even gather up the stones to confront the girl in plain sight.

4) It seems as though you all pick the nits without seeing the good bits. She complimented the students for their hard work. She encouraged people to go see the show because, while the musical as a whole didn't come together the way it should have, the individual contributions of the performers and crew members still made it a worthwhile experience nonetheless.

That's all I have to say about that. I realize that there are a lot of hurt feelings and bruised egos in light of this review. Even still, as the Opinion Editor, I am forced to contend everyday with opinions that differ from my own. However, I recognize every persons' natural right to hold and express these opinions and will facilitate this process whenever possible. Remember, Roberta didn't say the performers were bad or the musical was a complete flop. She said that it had its quirks, but everyone worked hard and it showed. What you all should realize is that, yes, Roberta isn't exactly the be-all-end-all dramatic authority at James Logan High School. You CAN disagree with her. However, when you reduce the issue to a war of “you worthless piece of…” this and “you have no idea what you’re talking about that”, you aren’t being terribly constructive either. If it offends you, fine. Respond. Take up arms if you must. But do NOT respond like a bunch of children, because then you’re no better than the offender allegedly is.

Posted by Ray Dequina, Courier Opinion Editor at Monday, March 05, 2007 18:37:01

I love Ray.

Although I didn't get a chance to see the musical, I just want to make a side note that there were more than one show. For those who only saw ONE show, maybe the one you saw was just almost perfect and the one she saw wasn't. Not every single show is necessarily exactly identical to the other if they are live.

This comment, of course, doesn't really apply to cast members or people that were there for all the shows.

That is all.

Posted by Carmen at Monday, March 05, 2007 19:30:36

whoa whoa...i was in the musical. the writer is just jealous that she does not have talent to perform on stage in front of others. shes not a musician. she doesn't know what "off key" is. Ms. Mcshane(choir director) even disagrees with that statement. it was "in key". the writer just wanted some attention. and now she got it. if it was broadway production we would of told her. WE'RE IN F*****G HIGH SCHOOL!!! stop trying to be a professional writer, u aren't one!! get a life!!!!!

Posted by School board member at Monday, March 05, 2007 19:36:34

Um, I don't mean to be paranoid or anything, but a lot of the comments, mostly the one's that hate on the article, seem to be really similar, and I wonder if they are really from a bunch of different people or just a few, using different names.

Posted by Wonderful at Monday, March 05, 2007 19:41:55

Are you really a school board member and a member of the cast, too? Wow!

Maybe you lie really easily, but that writer doesn't lie so easily.

Maybe that's it.

Posted by I don-t believe you at Monday, March 05, 2007 19:45:07

hell yes i hated theose rehersals...so f*****g long...i played ewart dunlop...and proud to say it...

Posted by School board member EWART DUNLOP at Monday, March 05, 2007 19:48:53

I went to my brother's middle school jazz band performance one Christmas. It was bad. Their timing was off, the drums were way too loud, and they didn't finish at the same time.

We told them that they were great, but we all knew the truth.

We in the audience didn't lie to each other about it. When we talked, we included the misplaced honks, but we didn't tell the kids.

So it's probably like learning there is no Santa for the first time. This may be the first time they heard an honest opinion.

Somehow, the arts are different than sports. If somebody sucks on the football team, the stats report it faithfully.

But if an actor or a singer or a musician or poet stinks, we're all supposed to stand at the end anyway, and cheer our heads off anyway.

Artists are such delicate flowers.

Posted by Water them at Monday, March 05, 2007 19:57:24

im guessing that the school board member is [edited] because i believe the other three have clear enough mind state to control what they say (yes i know them). and i admit that Bobbi's words were somewhat bruising to some of the actors/actresses egos, but still, she complimented their efforts. in my opinion i liked the show. and i'm pretty certain everyone knew their lines, a little stumble here and there, but i believe the turn out was fabulous.

Posted by hello hello hello is there anybody in th at Monday, March 05, 2007 19:59:04

TO THOSE WHO DID NOT LIKE THE MUSICAL AND THE PERSON WHO WROTE THIS ARTICLE:

HAVE SOME KNOWLEDGE ABOUT MUSICAL THEATRE BEFORE YOUR HAVE AN OPINION. BECAUSE YOUR IGNORANT COMMENTS AND ARTICLE BOTHER ME. AND IF YOU THINK YOUR OPINION IS RIGHT YOUR IGNORANCE SHOWS.
TO THOSE IN THE MUSICAL OR LIKE THE MUSICAL:

THERES NO NEED TO BE MEAN TO THOSE WHO ARE IGNORANT ABOUT MUSICAL THEATRE. JUST KNOW THAT YOU WORKED HARD TO PUT ON THE BEST SHOW.

Posted by calm the down people... at Monday, March 05, 2007 20:06:00

AARTI BHATNAGER MADE THE SHOW!! THERE WOULD ABSOLUTELY BE NO PLAY WITHOUT HER, AARTI YOU WERE TRULY THE BEST NO DOUBT, GANGSTTTTTAAA!! =)

Posted by -LIL S- at Monday, March 05, 2007 20:13:04

oh come on...shes taking enough harshness already bruh. im sure she meant no harm when she wrote this article down. she even called our attempt "heartfelt." though sounds like an insult, i'll take it as a compliment. :) we all had fun doing the show, and i'm pretty sure of it. so please. no more bashing! oh and one more thing, patrick is effing sexy buhd. just kidding! :P hahah

oh yeah and to the editor of comments, it was me. haha you're pretty good at this because it only took you like a couple of minutes to take it off. haha

Posted by patrick at Monday, March 05, 2007 20:18:15

I'm surprised you weren't satisfied with the show!!! We worked really hard and I thought we did great. Thank you for your criticism, however I am going to disagree with what you said about Joseph. Joseph was hella awesome and he played his part well! He is extremely talented and he wasn't unprepared. Even if he did stumble a little, don't call it unpreparedness!!! I LOVE JOSEPH!!! Anyways, thanks to everyone who came and watched!!! Hello cast! I miss you guys!

Posted by CatStart at Monday, March 05, 2007 20:35:55

i didnt see it ... but i know all my children did their best!...do be so mean when it is called for....but dont be so mean when you dont know how much time and effort the WHOLE CAST put into this.

Posted by someone in indiana at Monday, March 05, 2007 20:38:33

I think you've underestimated the cast and crew of The Music Man. Understand that the lines and lyrics to this particular show is amazingly difficult. I attended the Sunday matinee show, and thought it was a delight.
It's understandable that we would see flaws in a high school musical, but we can't forget to take notice their skill and dedication to such a production.

Posted by Dora at Monday, March 05, 2007 21:12:56

One more thing.

Yes, orchestra was kick ass.
hahaa.

Posted by Dora at Monday, March 05, 2007 21:15:04

THE BEST PART WAS WHEN THE JLHS BAND CAME IN OMG!

Posted by BAND GEEK at Monday, March 05, 2007 21:26:56

Did anyone who bashed the critic read the last line of her critique?

Just in case they didn't, here it is below.

" I would recommend seeing the musical purely for the effort that the students put into the production.
You can tell that the students have a passion for what they do and it shines through to produce a musical that is truly heartfelt. "

That doesn't sound insulting to THIS writer.

She was simply being honest.

You people are about to become adults very soon. Are you going to cry & whine everytime someone's opinion doesn't match yours?

How on Earth can you possibly improve, or even function, if you can't take criticism without falling apart?

As for the comments about the writer "not being a musician", she happens to be a very talented classical pianist. She is proficient on the cello and she is a professional dance instructor, choreographer, & performer. ("Professional", as in she actually gets PAID for what she does, morons!)

She had acted in local plays, did runway (for pay), sang for special choral groups (Gregorian Latin masses), & she has organized professional musical & runway shows for several years. She is a published poet & as for her musical education, she has taken music theory from a noted Stanford professor.

As for her "not making the play", she never tried out, because she was busy doing PAID gigs! (So that person's comment is not only invalid, but rather stupid.)

I've acted & written for The Asian American Theater, as well as for UC Santa Cruz & San Francisco State. I've encountered good & bad criticisms & I've learned from them. I've never whined about critiques, attacked critics, or cried like a baby, just because my ego was bruised.

I suspect that some of you who attacked Ms. Maas are young "men." It's about time you started acting like men & not like children who have to run to mommy everytime someone hurts your feelings.

i think YOU should "get a life" (or at least, try to improve your craft & not blame someone else for you lack of maturity OR talent.)

Posted by anthony at Monday, March 05, 2007 22:15:35

Do we really need WW3 to start because of one simple review on a high school online paper? Come on, guys...

Posted by Carmen at Monday, March 05, 2007 22:21:24

Yes I can back up my opinions.

Joseph messed up numerous times and I understand that he had a number of lines to recall. I was surprised that is all.

I saw the play on the opening night. The paint WAS wet. I even saw the cast hurridly painting during fifth period on the opening day. 'City Hall' wasn't even painted on the building yet!

I could not hear but one line during 'Pick-a-Little-Talk-a-Little' I asked a person in the audience if they could hear. Do you want to know their answer? Or are you afraid to take criticism from yet another? They told me that...you might want to grab a Kleenex...most of the words they couldn't understand. This is NOT the actors fault. The orchestra should have played to fit the singers and actors volume. There is some musical input for you!

Sorry to break it to you but you were out of key! I play the cello, a fretless instrument for those of you who don't know, and the instrument demands that I can indentify and play the various notes in tune due only to sound. In laymans terms I am required to have perfect pitch. I know when someone is off, and you were off. Not always mind you, but on a few numbers the chords did not match up...Who was singing the third...Who was the harmony....Who had the fifth? Sometimes I couldn't even tell.

The orchestra and band however were very much in tune as was Aarti and Victoria. I give kudos to those who truly deserve it.

I never tried out for the play because I had no intrest in involving myself in this production. I had performances and teaching gigs during the rehearsal times.

I do act. I do sing. I definitely dance. They are my passions. How dare you say that I have no experience. I have devoted years of my life, from the age of three, to music and dance. You don't know me. Who are you to judge? I had the right as a critic. I attended the play to accurately write a review. I had high hopes due to the fall play, Brighton Beach Memoirs, that was very well done and fluid. I was let down. I know that this play was a difficult endeavor. I understand the energy and vivacity that this musical demanded and I am not disparaging those who were involved. Some of you were brilliant. Some of you weren't. That's life.

Posted by Roberta at Monday, March 05, 2007 22:49:01

sweet butter biscuits that was a good play!

Posted by --DanieL-- at Monday, March 05, 2007 22:52:09

woah whats going on?? hahah. lets all chill, oh and dude, to anthony, i'm quite offended by you implying that the bashing is coming from us actORS because i'm chill about this, and i am pretty sure there are a few women doing some bashing. hm, all this negativity. hahah.

Posted by patrick at Monday, March 05, 2007 22:55:06

your little back up there, kinda made you look stuck up, and seem like you felt you are better than the production. i'm not saying that you are or not, but uhmm, i think you're making things worse.

Posted by anoniemouse. haha at Monday, March 05, 2007 23:03:46

I am only trying to negate the previous accusations of me being unqualified to critique the musical. I simply felt that in order to defend mytself I needed to list my qualifications.

Posted by Roberta at Monday, March 05, 2007 23:10:14

It's obvious that a large portion of the comments posted were writtten by people who worked on the musical. I saw the musical on the same night as the writer of this review and I must say I disagree with her. The play was decent and I felt that for the most part the actors remembered their lines and executed their parts successfully. While the quality of the show did not reach that of previous productions such as Into the Woods or Guys and Dolls, it was good fun and well worth the ten dollars.

What I do find somewhat appalling is the reaction from memebers of the cast and crew to their bad review. "We tried hard" and "the lines are hard to memorize" are not excuses for poor performances. Ms. Maus is a terrible writer if your standard for good journalism is lying to people in order to spare their feelings. She should not have to stifle her opinion to "show some school spirit."

Furthermore, if the cast and crew expect to be excused from criticism on account of being in high school then maybe they should consider that Ms. Maus is also in high school and that she used her knowledge of music and dance to critique the show.

The accusations about the writer only giving negative criticism because she didn't make the play are not only false (she never tried out) but also incredibly juvenile. Put the cherry lip balm down and learn to take criticism.

Posted by Annoyed at Monday, March 05, 2007 23:36:56

This is like Simon Cowell and American Idol.

The play was absolutely perfect; the author's opinion is inaccurate.

Posted by May contain sarcasm. at Tuesday, March 06, 2007 07:11:03

I concur with the rest of my fellow staff: so bloody what if a certain lady decides that the local High School musical is not 'up to standards'? Of all the people, the actors themselves have the responsibility to know whether they themselves did their best, a virtue which Maas clearly adressed.

I may not have attended this musical, or even been briefed on the nature of this assignment, but I know as a journalist that the commentary given against Maas' article is clearly opininated and without grounds. To the people who had worked on the musical, I say this: Observe the rules of intelligent debate. For the love of the Lord, show Miss Maas evidence that what she says is contrary to the truth. Also, kindly remember that this is a review. Therefore, it follows the modus oprendi of Entertainment news, in that the writer is entitled to her opinion. I only ask that the disgruntled folk writing their dissents to give the lady the respect she deserves, respect her experienced(albeit discomforting) criticism, and produce a better musical .

Posted by Your Emperor at Tuesday, March 06, 2007 09:18:24

take a chill pill. dont be so harsh. they worked hard. no need to be mean.

Posted by hellogoodbye at Tuesday, March 06, 2007 09:56:25

to whoever the teacher is (if there is one) who helps with the courier...i think you should read all the comments this is out of control and needs to be taken off...i feel sorry for bobby...she should not have to put up with this for stating her OPINION...and yes i worked on the show...it was not amazing, but the actors did work hard...re-read the review she is right about alomost all of it...just because it was written harshly doesnt mean you should hate on her...and to the writter dont try to defend what you wrote you did what you thought was right...but seriously this needs to be taken off...

<i>Advisor's Note: Thanks for the feedback.

Here at The Courier, we value our readers' opinions, good or bad, and we hope that our readers value the opportunity we offer to comment on our reporting.

We closely monitor the comments, and delete those that contain "bad" words, or are otherwise offensive, but we allow people with strong opinions to express them strongly.

We believe that such feedback is critical to our growth and development as writers. As a result of this episode and others, the staff of The Courier is well aware of the power of the forum the newspaper provides.

We are committed to continue offering the best, most trustworthy reporting that we can. We assure our readers that we'll be as truthful as we can, even if it sometimes angers people.</i>

Posted by STOPTHEMADNESS at Tuesday, March 06, 2007 10:26:11

i agree with u in some of the parts like for example in some of the songs i couldn't hear anything like in Pick-a-Little, but that Joseph was unprepared I have do disagree with u because he was awesome doing this role. Aarti and Joseph did a awesome job and with the offkey I have to said that the only ones that sound kind of offkey were the quartet when they sang.

Posted by someone who watched the show on Friday at Tuesday, March 06, 2007 15:45:52

The musical was great! I don't know what you were talking about, and yes Aarti was great, but so was Joseph! He was really good, and his singing was impeccable. Great job on the play everybody, the writer of this article is just jealous of your skills.. :D

Posted by Whhhaatttt at Tuesday, March 06, 2007 16:07:23

i think the quartet did a pretty decent job. it's really hard to sing in a four part harmony, since each of them can't really rely on each other. but yeahh, not great, but it was pretty good for highschool level.

Posted by myhairbangs at Tuesday, March 06, 2007 19:34:13

It seems that many people were offended by this article, but it seems that the comments were more offending to both the people that liked the musical and to those who didn't. I was in the musical, and I admit that Friday was not our best night, but even if Ms.Mass had come on another night and written a better review there would still be people out there who would think the musical was not so great. It seems to me that most of you are letting these opinions get under your skin a bit too far.

What would life be if people were not allowed to express their own opinions? BORING! This is just a situation where opinions are clashing, something that happens all of the time, so get over it.

To those of you who enjoyed the musical: I'm glad we were able to make you happy, and as long as it entertained you, you shouldn't care about what the other people think.

To those of you who didn't like the musical: I'm sorry we did not fulfill your expectations, and I hope that you will give Logan Drama another chance.

To those of you who didn't see the musical but happen to be reading this:
I hope all of this does not turn you off to all Logan Drama productions. I don't blame you for not wanting to come to any plays after reading this, because it seems a bit scary with all of the harsh comments being posted by people of both views.

I've heard that you can't have peace without war. This was our war and it is not possible to win because of the fact that we all have our own opinions, so I think it is time for peace (at least for now).

I've been having fun reading these comments and I think it is funny that so many people take this so seriously. Calm down and enjoy you life for a bit.

I hope that I have not offended anyone reading this beacuse that was not my intention, and I am not taking sides in the war, I just think it is time for the fire to be put out. =)

Posted by pippy at Tuesday, March 06, 2007 20:08:31

the opening scene was hecka funny and cool. major props to those who were in it. whadyatalk? hahah.

Posted by boomheadshot at Tuesday, March 06, 2007 20:10:33

Some stuff i suppose is correct, the orchastra did overpower us, some parts were off key, but the thing is i think you mainly mean the quartet, but what you need to understand is that those 4 are CHORAL singers, they had to change their singing styles completely, they had to throw away the choral rulebook to do this, it's basically telling a band person to go off key, or a dancer to fall, etc, and because of the way they sing, it becomes harder to sound good together, but they have to completely rely on each other, and yeah, of course victoria and aarti were great, but i think joseph did an awesome job too! =)

Posted by townsperson at Tuesday, March 06, 2007 21:31:33

is this like a record in comments for one article or something?? hahah.yeah quarteting was pretty hard.

Posted by patrick at Tuesday, March 06, 2007 22:33:30

oh i just read the article again, i think using "extremely" and saying they were unprepared is somewhat hurtful as you may see. and maybe if you changed the wording, none of this bashing could have happened. im not saying change it completely, but like, if you reworded it alittle, it would have helped a whole lot.

Posted by cheez-it at Tuesday, March 06, 2007 22:40:59

I also believe that it's just the way you worded things, if you said them in a different way, it wouldn't sound like it was a complete failure and would be a lot less hurtful

Posted by townsperson at Wednesday, March 07, 2007 06:46:36

Bwaaaaaaa, the review was fantastic! The truth hurts.. Haha. Nah everything was true jus hella extreme

Posted by Vicente Emiliano Sanchez at Wednesday, March 07, 2007 13:24:10

i agree with vicente. Kinda. somethings werent true and alot of things were exagerated.

Posted by shipoopi at Wednesday, March 07, 2007 18:01:16

I believe that Winthrop could have done a way better job than Harrold Hill.

Posted by Shiny Hippo at Friday, March 09, 2007 08:35:11

in all honesty the play wasn't as spectacular as people re making it out to be. yes, it was ok, but not only has logan presented way better, bobi has the right to write what she really thinks. you disagree: though. do better next time. i have absolutly no doubt that this girl spoke her mind, and for taht she has gained my respect, even though she lost the respect of some anonymous "professional actor".

Posted by ray-s jane at Friday, March 09, 2007 10:53:45

I thought the play was quite alright. Yes there were some parts that were boring and others that were quite fun and intersting to watch. There was one scene that confused me. Where Harold was singing to Marion, for me it came out of nowhere. But either than that it was very well!

Posted by Legon at Saturday, March 10, 2007 00:50:49

liek omg aarti is teh best eva!!!! go aarti whoooo!!!!

Posted by guess at Sunday, March 11, 2007 11:52:36

the above post is me

Posted by akash at Sunday, March 11, 2007 11:56:37

puh-leaseeeeeeee ppl, quite attacking her, that review wasnt even that bad, r u kidding me?

Posted by some student at Monday, March 19, 2007 12:33:35

Add Comment